Let’s resolve the debate over grilled cheese using Mayo Vs. Butter. In the realm of comfort food, few dishes hold a special place in our hearts quite like the classic humble grilled cheese sandwich. With its golden brown exterior, gooey melted cheese, and the unmistakable crunch as you sink your teeth into the toasty bread, this timeless creation has been a staple in kitchens worldwide. However, there’s a debate that has sparked culinary curiosity and ignited taste buds – the battle between mayo and butter as the ultimate grilled cheese sandwich spread.
The age-old practice of slathering butter on the bread before grilling is being challenged by a surprising contender – mayonnaise. As unconventional as it may sound, mayo enthusiasts swear by its ability to create a crispier, more flavorful crust. But can it truly dethrone the reigning champion, butter, known for its rich, indulgent taste?
Devotees of the grilled cheese sandwich express their opinions on every element. Be it the choice of bread, whether it’s classic white type of bread or a flavorful sourdough, or thick Texas toast. Or the ideal combination of cheese slices that produces that irresistibly ooey-gooey melted interior.
The current buzz in the grilled cheese aficionado community centers around the different fat options in making the perfect grilled cheese sandwich. Everyone seems to have an opinion on the best choice of spread for coating the outside of each slice of bread before it sizzles in the skillet, a crucial factor in achieving that perfect crispy bread exterior for this delectable sandwich. But what is the best way?
Will the mayo-infused masterpiece reign supreme, or will the buttery classic hold its ground as the undisputed king of grilled cheese? Which one is the better choice? Let the sizzling duel commence!
Grilled Cheese using Mayo Vs. Butter Taste Test
In this epic showdown, we decided to put these two condiment champions to the test, examining various aspects such as ease of spreading, prep time, flavor, aroma, color, texture, evenness of browning, and the all-important factor – whether the exteriors felt greasy. Join us on this delicious journey as we uncover the truth behind the age-old question: butter or mayo? While one is going to make the best grilled cheese?
Testing Process
We used a standard grilled cheese recipe using two slices of bread and two slices of cheese. With butter or mayo spread on the outside of the bread slices.
Bread Choices
To conduct a fair and thorough comparison, we designed a meticulous testing process. We opted for the classic white bread. While chewy sourdough, hearty wheat bread, garlic bread, or crusty artisanal options undoubtedly bring diverse flavors and textures to sandwiches, they might not be the ideal choices for grilled cheese. The introduction of additional flavors can overshadow the star of the show—the gooey cheese within.
Moreover, the robust crusts, when toasted, can become overly sharp, posing the risk of shredding the delicate roof of your mouth. In the realm of grilled cheese simplicity, sometimes less elaborate bread options allow the cheesy goodness to shine without unnecessary distractions or potential mouthful challenges.
Variety of Cheeses
We used a blend of cheeses known for their melt-in-your-mouth goodness. Melting cheeses used include American cheddar, mozzarella, or fontina to ensure it melts before the bread burns. For a uniform test we used American cheese as it is a type of cheese that melts quickly, with good flavor.
Skillet
Nonstick pans heat up quickly and retain heat effectively, ensuring that grilled cheese sandwiches brown evenly under these conditions. While a well-seasoned cast-iron skillet, also equipped with a nonstick surface, offers an alternative, it requires a longer heating time and is not renowned for uniform heat distribution. Stainless steel skillets rank as our least preferred choice due to their tendency to stick to food without the addition of extra oil.
Each sandwich was cooked in the same non-stick pan. Using medium heat, with precise temperature control to ensure consistency. We assessed each spread’s performance in a head-to-head battle, carefully noting the differences at every stage of the grilling process.
Ease of Spreading
One of the first considerations was the ease of spreading each condiment. Cold butter is not spreadable, it will tear holes in the bread when trying to spread on the side of each slice of bread even if you scrape off the butter with the knife in thin ribbons. Additional time is needed to soften the butter. Butter, a familiar and pliable choice, glided effortlessly across the bread, coating it evenly.
Mayo, surprisingly, held its ground, offering a smooth and convenient application. Best thing, its ease of use with no additional time is needed to soften the spread as with the butter. The ease of spreading set the tone for the showdown, leaving us eager to discover which spread would triumph.
Advanced Prep
For those who value convenience, the question of advanced prep is crucial. Butter, often requiring softening or melting, can demand a bit of forethought. Mayo, on the other hand, requires no such preparation, making it the quicker option for those impromptu grilled cheese cravings.
Flavor, Aroma, Color, Texture
The heart of any grilled cheese lies in its flavor, aroma, color, and texture. Butter lent its traditional richness, imparting that nostalgic taste we all love. The mayonnaise, surprisingly, delivered a unique flavor profile – a tangy, zesty twist that complemented the cheese. Aroma-wise, both spreads contributed to the irresistible scent wafting through the kitchen.
When it came to color and texture, the results were intriguing. Butter produced a golden-brown hue with a slightly denser crust, while mayo surprised us with a lighter, airier texture and an equally appealing color.
Evenness of Browning
Achieving the perfect even browning is an art form in the grilled cheese world. Butter displayed its mastery, providing a consistent and beautifully browned exterior. Mayo, however, presented a slight challenge, with some areas browning more quickly than others, requiring a more vigilant eye during the cooking process.
Greasy Exteriors
Finally, the often-debated issue of greasiness. Butter, true to its nature, left a slightly greasy residue on the exterior. Mayo, surprisingly, produced a cleaner finish, with less noticeable grease, offering a lighter feel to the touch.
Conclusion
As the sizzling face-off between butter and mayo concluded, we found ourselves torn between tradition and innovation.
We preferred the flavor of our grilled cheese prepared with butter. The brown butter caramelization is hard to beat. Butter, with its timeless appeal, delivered that familiar richness, while mayo surprised us with its unique tanginess and crunchier finish.
The choice ultimately depends on personal preference, with both spreads bringing their own flair to the beloved grilled cheese experience. Whether you’re someone who cherishes the classics or an adventurous soul seeking a flavor revolution, the spread wars have added a new layer of excitement to the world of grilled cheese.
In the end, both are delicious options. May your skillets sizzle and your taste buds rejoice in the eternal quest for the perfect bite!
Alternative Grilled Cheese Spread Views Butter Vs. Mayo
There are other prominent sites that have conducted this same test. Here are the results:
Southern Living recommends the mayo over the butter. However, they also point out that you must use a full-fat, traditional mayo. Reduced fat and light mayonnaise varieties have a higher water content, which can lead to a soggy sandwich.
Taste of Home suggests Using mayo instead of butter as it results in a rich, golden brown exterior, and some say the taste is even better than butter.
Tasting Table preferred the mayonnaise grilled cheese as the overall winner. Their tasting panel preferred the even browning over the butter-slathered sandwich. However, the tasters preferred the grilled cheese prepared with butter. The sweet nuttiness of the brown butter caramelization was hard to beat.
The Cookful preferred the convenience of the mayonnaise, yet the taste of the butter still prevailed.
Why is Butter a Classic Choice?
Butter has earned its status as the classic choice for making grilled cheese sandwiches for several reasons, rooted in tradition, flavor, and culinary heritage. Here are some key factors that contribute to butter’s classic appeal:
Rich Flavor
Butter is prized for its rich, indulgent flavor. When melted and spread onto bread, it imparts a classic and comforting taste that many people associate with the quintessential grilled cheese experience. The buttery flavor complements the gooey, melted cheese perfectly.
Cultural Tradition
Butter has been a staple in many culinary traditions around the world for centuries. Its use in cooking and baking, including grilled cheese sandwiches, is deeply ingrained in cultural practices, making it a natural choice for those seeking to recreate familiar and time-tested recipes.
Versatility
Butter is a versatile ingredient that serves various purposes in cooking and baking. Its ability to enhance the flavor and texture of bread while contributing to the browning process makes it an ideal choice for grilled cheese. Its versatility extends beyond grilled cheese to many other culinary applications.
Texture and Mouthfeel
When melted, butter contributes to a dense and slightly crunchy exterior on the bread, providing a satisfying contrast to the soft, gooey interior. The texture and mouthfeel that butter imparts to the grilled cheese sandwich are key components of its classic appeal.
Buttery Aroma
The aroma of butter as it melts and combines with the bread’s warmth is distinctive and enticing. This aromatic quality adds to the sensory pleasure of the grilled cheese experience and enhances the overall enjoyment of the dish.
Crispy Crust
Butter helps achieve a desirable crispy crust on the bread, enhancing the overall texture of the grilled cheese. The golden-brown exterior achieved with butter contributes to the visual appeal of the sandwich.
Nostalgia
For many, the classic grilled cheese made with butter evokes a sense of nostalgia. It harks back to childhood memories, family meals, and the simple joy of enjoying a timeless comfort food.
While mayonnaise and other spreads have gained popularity for their unique advantages, butter’s classic choice status is deeply ingrained in culinary tradition and the collective experience of generations. The enduring appeal of butter in grilled cheese sandwiches speaks to its timeless and comforting qualities that continue to resonate with people around the world.
Does mayo have advantages over butter when making grilled cheese?
Yes, mayonnaise does have several advantages over butter when it comes to making grilled cheese, and these advantages have contributed to the growing popularity of mayo as a grilled cheese spread. Here are some key advantages:
Crispier Exterior
One of the main advantages of using mayonnaise is that it tends to create a crispier exterior on the grilled cheese sandwich. The combination of ingredients in mayonnaise, including oil and eggs, contributes to a golden and crunchy crust.
Even Browning
Mayo often results in a more even browning across the bread. This can be particularly appealing for those who prefer a uniform color and texture on their grilled cheese.
Ease of Spreading
Mayonnaise is generally easier to spread directly onto bread, especially if it’s kept at room temperature. Unlike butter, which may require softening or melting, mayo is ready to go straight from the jar.
No Burning Issues
Butter has a lower smoke point compared to mayonnaise. This means that when cooking at higher temperatures, butter can burn and impart a less desirable taste. Mayo, with its higher smoke point, is less prone to burning.
Distinctive Flavor
Mayo introduces a unique tangy flavor to the grilled cheese, adding a twist to the traditional taste. This can be a delightful variation for those looking to experiment with different flavor profiles.
Less Greasy Texture
Mayo tends to leave the grilled cheese with a less greasy texture compared to butter. This can be appealing to individuals who prefer a lighter feel in their sandwiches.
No Advanced Prep Required
Unlike butter, which may need to be softened or melted before spreading, mayonnaise requires no advanced preparation. This makes it a convenient choice for those looking to whip up a grilled cheese sandwich on the fly.
While mayonnaise offers these advantages, it’s important to note that the choice between mayo and butter ultimately comes down to personal preference. Some may prefer the rich, traditional flavor of butter, while others enjoy the unique qualities that mayo brings to the table. The grilled cheese experience can be a highly subjective one, and experimenting with both spreads allows for a delightful exploration of different textures and tastes.
Explore our other cooking tips.
Easy Sandwich Recipes
